Erin PhinneyNovember 20264 min read
Your Best AI Visibility Play Is a Great Piece on Someone Else’s Site
Why It Works Series: Casey Hill’s unpaid content collabs with Growth Unhinged and MKT1 now drive 60-70% of DoWhatWorks’ new newsletter signups.
Everyone is ears up about AEO. Most marketers I talk to are asking some version of the same question: how do we get recommended?
Casey Hill has an answer, and he didn’t build it for AEO. When I interviewed him for Founding Voices, he walked me through the content collabs he runs at DoWhatWorks. They’re unpaid and fully earned, and today 60 to 70% of his new newsletter signups come from three recommendation engines, sending people to him daily from collabs he did months ago.
Don’t get me wrong, paid partnerships have their place. But this one cost $0 and keeps paying out. Here’s my (marketer) take on why it works.
Earn it with something worth reading
Casey focused on organic, earned content. For that content to perform, it needs to actually be valuable and unique, so he writes the entire piece himself before he asks for anything.
Pick outlets where your buyers already live
Growth Unhinged and MKT1 readers are exactly who DoWhatWorks sells to. Casey is careful not to write off small outlets: if you sell enterprise and a 500-person newsletter could land you one good deal, that math works. But if roughly 1% of readers take a next step, a bigger outlet might be what makes the economics work.
“We’ve had the most impact from those larger but high relevancy outlets.”
Bring data nobody else has
For Kyle Poyar, Casey wrote up what DoWhatWorks learned from 20,000 experiments. When he noticed outlets were hungry for content on MCP, he pitched one of them on compiling what he was hearing from companies like Stripe and Glean. The answer was an enthusiastic yes.
“Number one is you need to really understand the outlet. And what they care about, like, what are they writing about?”
If you have data, you can copy this. Your own numbers give you a point of view no one else can replicate, and when that’s fitted to their audience, it’s hard for an editor to say no.
Don’t come in hot with a CTA
Nothing gives a partner the heebie-jeebies faster than a thinly veiled promo. Casey’s first touch is one question, and the CTA isn’t part of it.
“I was looking at doing this piece. I thought of you, your audience, like, do you think this would be an interesting article?”
Once the relationship is built, outlets like Kyle’s usually add a little CTA at the bottom on their own.
Keep showing up after it goes live
Most people do the collab and peace out, leaving the other side to do all the work. Casey promotes every piece to his own audience, so the partner gets extra reach and a reason to work with him again. His test is simple: if you wouldn’t share it in your own newsletter, why are you doing it?
Why it compounds, and what it means for AEO
That reach compounds, and so does the authority. Every credible outlet that recommends or links to you keeps sending people long after the post is old news. That’s where Casey’s 60 to 70% comes from.
For anyone working on AEO, these are the same kinds of sources LLMs lean on. As of January 2026, only 23% of what LLMs cite about a brand comes from the brand’s own site, and earned media makes up 48%, including 16% from editorial sites and independent media.1 AEO is an ever-moving target, but the newsletters recommending Casey are exactly those sources.
The lesson
Writing great content for someone else’s site has a short-term and a long-term payoff. In the short term, you get in front of the right audience, and for Casey that’s driven a ton of business. In the long term, it keeps sending people your way through recommendations, links, and the LLMs that lean on them, months after it publishes.
So when you’re deciding where to spend your content time, think past launch week. Write something the outlet’s readers can’t get anywhere else, and keep promoting it after it ships so it keeps working for you.
Your best AI visibility play might be a great piece on someone else’s site.
Casey’s full playbook is on Trove, along with the Growth Unhinged and MKT1 pieces that earned him the features. Worth the read! https://thetrove.io/artifacts/483
Sources
- 1. Omniscient Digital, “How LLMs Source Brand Information,” Cate Dombrowski, January 8, 2026. 240 branded prompts across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, AI Mode and AI Overviews, 23,387 sources.