Erin PhinneyNovember 20266 min read
Casey Hill Starts With What the Other Side Gets
Ten lessons from DoWhatWorks’ CMO on campaigns people want to say yes to, from 150+ customers posting to a $2.1M pipeline LinkedIn series.
“Why would someone share this?”
Casey Hill built every post in his viral LinkedIn series around that one question, and it’s how he approaches pretty much everything. He’s exceptional at understanding the exchange of value. Whether the other side is a customer, a partner, or a prospect, he figures out what they give, what they get, and builds the campaign around it. That’s why people say yes, and why they keep sharing.
Here’s what we learned:
Ask why someone would share it
At DoWhatWorks, Casey wanted reach beyond his own channels. So instead of promoting DoWhatWorks, he launched a series called “[Company] is the only company I have seen do this,” spotlighting rare website moves from B2B brands. One early post about Clay passed 500,000 views, and Clay became a customer.
“I hypothesized that if we created content with a built-in incentive for other brands to share it, celebrating their innovative work rather than just promoting ourselves, it would create a self-reinforcing distribution loop that drove business.”
The featured brands got a flattering spotlight, so they shared it, and some paid to promote it as thought leader ads. The community started DMing him standout websites every week, which fed the next round. The series has driven 6.6 million views across 22 viral posts and $2.1M in pipeline. Read how he built the flywheel.
Make the ask small and specific
At ActiveCampaign, asking customers what they loved about the product got a couple of responses. The ask was too open. What worked was one prompt on one day: this Friday, tell people why you migrated to ActiveCampaign and where you came from. More than 150 customers posted. Once it was working, ActiveCampaign put real budget behind it too, with more than $300K in paid promo on customers’ posts.
“We had a very specific ask on a very specific day with very specific things that we would do in return that were valuable to that individual, and they weren’t monetary.”
Read the full story and ask Casey a question on Trove.
Ask what they need, then deliver it
A $50 gift card isn’t going to excite a VP. Casey’s customers were marketers who wanted visibility, so his team featured them on the ActiveCampaign site and shared their podcasts and webinars in a room with 250 people. One customer got 19 five-star reviews within an hour of an episode dropping.
“What do they care about? What do they value?”
Adjust the give to what your customers care about and what they’re focused on right now.
Be the connector
The most valuable thing you can give a customer or partner is business. Shopify did a version of this with a holiday catalog featuring 20 of its customers’ brands. The simpler version is an introduction: someone wants to be a customer of theirs, so you make the handoff.
“You’re never going to get more loyal customers than if you literally hand them business.”
Write the piece your partner’s audience wants
Casey writes the entire article before he asks for anything. For Kyle Poyar’s Growth Unhinged, it was what DoWhatWorks learned from 20,000 experiments. For Emily Kramer’s MKT1, how websites are changing in the age of AI. The outlet gets free, original research its readers can’t find anywhere else, and that’s Casey’s leverage. In return, he gets in front of exactly the right audience. No paid placements, and no CTA on the first touch.
“I run a newsletter. If someone had something that is very well researched, sharing a lot of their stats, their data, and they’re like, we’ll do this thing for you. I’m like, that sounds great… I get something that’s content for free.”
Read his content collab formula.
Show up after it publishes
In most partnerships, one side does the collab and then disappears. DoWhatWorks promotes every piece, which is a big reason the same outlets keep working with them. The long tail surprised him most: 60 to 70% of DoWhatWorks’ new newsletter signups come from three recommendation engines, months after the collabs ran.
“Oh no, I would never share that. Okay, then why are you doing it?”
Pay to boost their episode, not your ad
At Bonjoro, Casey did 200+ podcasts in one year. After an episode aired, he’d offer the host $300 or $500 to promote it. The host got free promotion for their show, and Bonjoro got a message that came from the host instead of an ad.
“That $500, that $1,000, very often is so much more successful from that third-party vantage point than it would be if you were to run the same ad, because it feels more promotional.”
Get feedback you can act on
Before his board game hit Kickstarter, Casey playtested in local game stores and ran thousands of surveys. Asking people to rate it from 1 to 10 barely helped. Pointed questions did, and they showed him it was a family game, not the high fantasy game he thought he’d built.
“Where was someone really confused in the game? What was a moment where they were, like, they really got into it?”
Own the gaps on your team
Two or three weeks before launch, the professor making Casey’s Kickstarter video walked away and told him he was hard to work with. Casey’s first reaction was that it would ruin everything. Then he admitted the scope had grown because of his own edits, apologized, and they finished a video that became a big part of the campaign.
“A lot of times what you perceive as weaknesses or gaps in your team is really a leadership problem, and you have to kind of own that and figure out how to solve it.”
Gift experiences, not cash
Casey once gifted a stay at a treehouse over a waterfall in Oregon. He’s sure a $1,000 check wouldn’t have landed the same way, because the best gives are the ones people wouldn’t buy for themselves.
“Logically, if someone’s like, do you want an $860 Airbnb or $1,000, everyone would be like, well, I want $1,000 because I could just go buy it. But people don’t splurge on themselves.”
Best questions from the week
Danielle Messler asked how he ties LinkedIn content to revenue or pipeline. His answer: “For orgs that have a smaller number of overall leads (agencies or enterprise SaaS for example), I think you just use direct attribution. The vast majority of our leads either bring up organically that they heard about us from my LinkedIn, or if we ask, they mention my LinkedIn.”
Dave Burgess asked how Casey vetted the brands featured in his LinkedIn series. His answer: “I always select based on what’s innovative and then share with the teams once the content is viral vs vetting or hitting up the teams beforehand.”
Ask Casey your question
Casey’s stories are live on Trove, and he’s still answering questions. Go ask him one.