A rebrand gets a bad rap. It’s this big, complicated thing nobody wants to touch, kind of a black hole that’s costing the company money while everyone waits to see what comes out the other side. At Elastic Path, I wanted to run ours so that we were making decisions and moving forward every week.
Why we needed it
The company has been around for about 26 years. In 2020, Elastic Path acquired Moltin, a small startup in Boston. That brought a new CEO and a change in the underlying product we predominantly sell for new business. We were a very different company than we’d been for 20 years, but the market still saw us as an old, legacy company. I call us an old startup.
I pitched the rebrand to our executive team in my first 30 days. It took over a year to get approved. Maybe not the first thing I’d recommend a new director pitch, but when it got the green light, I knew exactly how I wanted to run it.
One agency, weekly sprints, one voice of feedback
We hired @Focus Lab, a smaller niche agency, to do both our messaging and our visual identity. They worked in weekly sprints, so we got deliverables from them every week.
The deal on our side was that every week I owed them one voice of coalesced feedback. I met weekly with a key group: our CEO, our head of sales, our head of product and a few other key leaders. Then I synthesized what we heard, decided what made sense to share, and hit send. The agency never got six conflicting opinions. They got one.
That cadence is a real commitment, and you have to know what you’re signing up for. Before we started, I had to get buy-in that our executive team would meet and give feedback every single week. That was the price of admission, and it was worth it.
A log of every decision
I also became obsessive about documentation. I have a log of every key decision we made throughout the process. Whenever someone asks me later, why did you do this, or why did you do that, the reasoning is right there. You’re going to forget these things.
One of the biggest decisions was whether to change the company name. We debated it and decided not to, because the name still serves us. That’s in the log too.
Why I ran it this way: I’d done it the other way before
This was my second end-to-end rebrand. The first was at SmartBear, where I worked with our creative director to update our brand strategy, positioning, story and brand and product architecture. The orange gear that looks like a bear, our “Gear Bear,” came out of that work.
It was a great project, and I learned a ton. But we ran it the traditional way: a consultant for messaging and story, a separate agency for visual identity, and the classic cycle. You brief them, they go away for a few weeks, they come back with options, you give feedback, and they go away again. You never see their iterative work, and the gaps between rounds are where projects stall.
We also didn’t keep a record of our decisions at SmartBear and that can make answering the inevitable questions laborious. At Elastic Path, that was the first thing I fixed.
What changed
Every week we got closer to the finish line. We weren’t waiting a month for a big reveal and hoping it landed. The executives who’d be living with the brand were in the room weekly, so it was never a surprise. And today, if anyone questions a call we made, I can show them why we made it.
Key metrics
Weekly deliverables from one agency across messaging and visual identity
One consolidated round of exec feedback every week
A full decision log covering every key call, including keeping the company name
Second end-to-end rebrand, run differently based on lessons from the first