At Elastic Path there were a lot of thoughts about who our ICP should or shouldn't be, both in type of company and size of company. Some leaders wanted to go upmarket which is very common in tech. Everyone always wants to go upmarket.
But you can't wave a magic wand and declare something your ICP when very few of your customers, and none of your inbound prospects or current opportunities, are upmarket. We can run a campaign that tries to go there. Until we see success there, it's not our ICP.
Why marketing should own this conversation
In marketing we sit in a really interesting position. We see who's coming through the front door, who we're winning, who we're resonating with, and where the product gaps are, because we're listening to the calls. I think marketing should be the primary orchestrator of defining the ICP, alongside sales and product.
Product is the third leg of that stool, and it sometimes doesn't get the respect it deserves in these conversations. If product isn't releasing functionality that's buzzworthy and relevant to your ICP, your announcements will flop when you try to make noise in market.
Narrowing the ICP
About 18 months ago, I led the work to refine and narrow our ICP to B2B brands, and I got product and sales aligned on it. It shapes product development, because we want to release functionality specific to our ideal buyers. It shapes how we go to market and who sales talks to. And it's right in our homepage H1: for B2B brands.
That was a challenging call. We have happy B2C customers with recognizable logos like Serena & Lily. Were we alienating them by claiming B2B? The answer is no. Even after changing the messaging, about 20% of our qualified opportunities last quarter were B2C. We're not shutting the door on them. We're just not focusing on them for acquisition. That allows marketing and sales to focus on the ICP with the highest win rate.